@Jeremy Thanks, the file contents are the most useful thing you’ve posted, because they show the 01-… file on your server is not FOG’s. I owe you a correction on that too: yesterday I took “the file is there” as proof the fix landed. It wasn’t — that file is yours.
1. Everything in /tftpboot/pxelinux.cfg/ is hand-written, and it’s the wrong format for pxe boot. 01-88-a2-9e-53-34-c0, boot.scr, default and default-arm all contain a U-Boot script (setenv …, tftp …, booti …). pxe boot doesn’t run scripts; it parses a PXELINUX-style config (label, kernel, initrd, append), finds no labels in yours, and does nothing. That’s your “downloads pxelinux, but then stops”, and it was never going to work regardless of the FOG bugs I fixed. Please don’t hand-write anything under pxelinux.cfg/: FOG owns the 01-<mac> names there, and its periodic reconcile deletes any 01- file whose host has no active task, so your file would vanish anyway. (boot.scr, if you ever wanted one, has to be a mkimage-wrapped binary in the TFTP root, not text under pxelinux.cfg/. You don’t need it; the pxe path is the whole thing.)
To get FOG’s file: run the updater once more (PR #1679 is merged), then in the web UI queue a Capture task for Raspberry-test. Within a moment /tftpboot/pxelinux.cfg/01-88-a2-9e-53-34-c0 will be replaced by a file starting # Generated by FOG Project with kernel arm_Image and initrd arm_init.cpio.gz, and /tftpboot/arm_Image and /tftpboot/arm_init.cpio.gz will appear beside it. Paste that file back here. Your host settings are fine: arm64, image set, primary disk /dev/sda. (acpi=off in the kernel arguments does nothing on a Pi; harmless.)
2. saveenv failed because there is no SD card, so nothing you setenv survives a reboot. That’s actually fine for the end goal: the default bootcmd=bootflow scan already does DHCP and then pxe get / pxe boot on its own, no environment needed. So for a cardless fleet you don’t need bootcmd at all. What you do need is DHCP to work inside U-Boot, which brings us to:
3. DHCP. netretry yes was doing its job (“Retry time exceeded; starting again” is it retrying, not failing). With STP confirmed on the switch, the port is most likely blocking for the first ~30 seconds after U-Boot resets the NIC. One test settles it: run setenv netretry yes then dhcp, and wait a full 60 seconds before judging. If it gets a lease on the second or third cycle, that’s STP, and the fix is PortFast / edge-port on the Pi ports (the default bootflow scan won’t retry long enough on its own, and without an SD card you can’t persist netretry). If it still has nothing after 60 seconds, then it isn’t timing: check OPNsense’s DHCP log (Services → DHCPv4 → Log) for 88:a2:9e:53:34:c0 during the attempt and tell me whether a DISCOVER arrives and whether an OFFER goes out.
Once DHCP works and FOG’s file is in place, bootflow scan (or dhcp; pxe get; pxe boot by hand) should pull arm_Image and boot FOS. If it stops anywhere after that, the last lines on screen are what I need — pasted text, not a photo, if there’s any way to capture it.
