@george1421 Hi,

Thanks for your reply. Its strange. I am working with (almost exclusively) early 2012 hardware. My older Imacs 2009-2011 afaict pxe boot fine image with FOG w/o issue. The problem comes along when, I try to image our macbooks. They display different levels of progress before they flat out hang. I had one mbpx,y I’m almost sure it was a 3rd gen intel just can’t find it right now. I may be being processed to go out the door to our clients.

Yes the 2019 verison of ipxe was executed from a boot of clonezill 3.1.x the version I would attempt to boot from ventory stick or from an imaged usb stick would display an error regarding not having efi capability and/or hang or return to the ventoy menu. If I just let them be long enough the MBP would just restart.

So I did attempted to roll my own and ran into the same problem with the oobox downloadable iso/zip file. Hang… I am researching w/o much success with how clonezilla compiled their ipxe menu entry or how to just plain add efi capability to ipxe.iso/zip and burn it to a usb stick. I just am not knowledable enough to formulate a good question or find what I am looking for (cause I don’t know:))

So thanks again for your reply. I have a large donations of older MBP’s coming just before the holidays and I would lik to be able to make it rain.

Regards,

UPDATE –

@astrugatch

I just wanted to follow up on this. I realize this thread is ancient but I feel this is still very much relevant. We ended up going with Mosyle (PAID) for our MAC / Apple MDM. We are unhappy with it. It does not meet either myself or the instructors expectations.

You are 100% correct, Mosyle does not meet the expectations of a true MDM. It’s clunky and the support is not great. I have not looked at munki yet but am going to pursue that to try and make the most of what we have. I am also looking at another product called FileWave, which is supposed to work very well with pretty much every platform (minus Linux). FileWave is a paid service / subscription.

Thanks again!

@george1421

Thanks George. No but I will now that I have time machine back ups. Can I use mac-boot to create the stick then just update those 2 things?

Hi,
I’m trying to PXE these Apple M1s using asahi, u-boot and the Fos USB stick. Has anyone succeeded yet?
For now, I can launch a ipxe.efi but have a crash after the second line (“Features: DNS, HTTP…”)

Thanks a lot 🙂

@Sebastian-Roth said in Boot pxe from partition instead of USB:

https://wiki.fogproject.org/wiki/index.php?title=FOG_on_a_MAC#Using_bless

I understand the bless comand but will this not change the boot partition permanently? I dont have a problem to boot from the right partion.

Hi,

no I have the time to deal with this problem again.

Again further details how I have done it:

made a fat 32 partition in my intel iMac copied all the files from my working USB-Boot-Stick to the partition Started the mac by holding the option key No I could choice the boot partition (my new Fat 32 boot partition with all files from the working usb-boot-stick) got the eror:
app.efi: LocateProtocoll(AppleLogging) succeeded
error: no such partition

could it be that there have to be done other work that the fat32 boot partition will find the exact file to boot.
I have made the USB-boot sticks with Rufus. I dont kow if there were made changes by rufus.

thank you very much.
Mathew

@Sebastian-Roth Yes. Thanks

@pjv While the fog-client has an implementation for AD join and rename (see code) I am not sure this is working. The C# code actually calls a bash script (osxbind.sh) which I have no idea about.

@thedark5776 said in Realizando imagen de MAC:

So in order for the Mac to connect to the FOG server, does Fog have to handle DCHP itself?

No. You can try to make your existing DHCP server to properly answer the Mac bootp protocol or use other methods like “bless” (see mentioned wiki article) or USB boot (George’s answer). I don’t have a Mac myself for testing so this is all just from information gathered over the years.

@george1421 Cool. Is the T2 Kernel known to address this specific issue?

@sebastian-roth That is on the list of things to do next.

@george1421 Awesome - this worked. It booted from the stick fine and I was able to perform a quick registration. I started to capture the drive and it worked up until it came to the APFS portion. I ran into the apfsclone.c: bitmap error, like with the hackintosh.

@george1421
I saw that the boot stick has a masterboot record and the drive in the imac is GPT.
Could you imagine that this is the Problem why the FOS linux didnt boot?

@Matthew-Wyneken I have never tried the fog-client on Mac OS X myself I have to say. It’s been other developers working on this part. Though I am wondering if the instructions given in the wiki are not up to date anymore and if we should update documentation?

Would you be so kind and let us know what steps you took and what is missing in the documentation?

@Smoblikat Well that sounds not too bad. Got an address from the DHCP?! Wow! Did you see that communication in Wireshark?

With FOG you’d run: chain tftp://x.x.x.x/default.ipxe (put in the FOG server IP instead of x.x.x.x…)

@smoooo I replied to your pm with the script I use to expand OSX partitions.

Also, the prohibitory symbol (crossed out circle) could also mean an incompatible OS for the hardware, I do a little bit with snow leopard to make it work on unsupported hardware, and it usually involves a kernel swap at a minimum to get old OS’s booting on new hardware.

Not sure if youre still having issues with corestorage or not, but “diskutil cs list” will show you your corestorage groups, which would typically need to be deleted before cloning or modifying partitions (you would get the prohibitory symbol from this too).

Also, just as a random tidbit, you can install OSX on an HFS+ disk all the way up to 10.13 (never tested 10.14+, might still work) if you run the installer from the commandline and use the

–converttoapfs NO

switch for the installer. This might give you a LITTLE bit more flexibility as far as being able to read partitions/volumes from linux utilities (APFS support is much harder to come by).

@Smoblikat If you have 2017 (guess) or newer Apple started including the T2 chip, which is the security controller for the apple devices. All communications go through this T2 chip. You need a special FOS Linux kernel to get these systems to image correctly.

I would say lets create a new thread and we can discuss in detail there.

@george1421 thanks for your reply, i will retest as per your instructions