HP Stream 11 x360 (HP 11-ab00x) Hangs after init.xz
I have looked elsewhere and found many posts such as this one https://forums.fogproject.org/topic/10789/boot-file-testing-for-sr/57
where I found some alternate ipxe efi files that I have tried to no avail.
Here’s the story.
I’ve got this tablet, it has been imaged before succsessfully but after it’s been sitting for quite some time I wanted to test it for a new use and found that it can’t be imaged now.
I’m on fog 1.5.4
It does have a usb_nic that I know is working (works for many other devices on my network) and has_usb_nic=1 is set on the host.
I can get into the fog menu and I can register the host via pxe. The hang only happens when queued for an image task.
It is using uefi and currently there is no os to boot to, which made updating the firmware to the latest version a challenge, but I was able to get that to update and the bios/firmware is the latest which sadly didn’t change anything.
So I’m not sure what to try next here. I’ve tried all the included .efi files in tftpboot and the ones found in the google drive link that was in the forum post I linked here.
My process of getting this particular device to boot involves getting to an efi shell via a usb bootable version of rEFInd. Loading the efi driver for my usb ethernet adapter, then executing the ipxe files I have copied to a separate usb drive, which has worked rather well and I have documented in the forum elsewhere.
Sorry that this is a little scatterbrained.
@JJ-Fullmer Ok, I just prepared a first one to test for you - download
1_bzImageand put in /var/www/html/fog/service/ipxe. Then edit this host’s settings and set this kernel as Host Kernel and see what you get.
I used a fairly recent kernel version 4.19.13 and so we might even see different behaviour than when we tested some months ago.
@JJ-Fullmer Sorry for the long delay again. I am back on track now to tackle this. Do you think you can get it back for some testing in the next couple of days? I am preparing debug kernels already. So I’ll be ready to go when you are.
@JJ-Fullmer I’ll look through the code again in the next days and post new kernels to test if you are available and have a device to test.
@Sebastian-Roth I do still have it on hand if you have any new ideas. I just ended up going through my image prep process with a fresh install of windows as if I was making the image on this computer. It was much much slower of course, but it worked. This one in particular has been deployed now, but if we have something promising I could probably pull it back from production and give the user something else in the interim.
@JJ-Fullmer Ohhhh my …, must have lost track of this in the middle of a hectic months. Sorry! Do you still have those devices at hand to test?
@JJ-Fullmer As the kernel code is changing and I never saved that dirty hack as a proper patch I need to make this up again from memory all the time. So possible my hack was just wrong the first time. I now added some debug output to see if I am doing things at the right place. Please download from the same URL again, I just updated the binary a minute ago: https://fogproject.org/kernels/Kernel.SR.SKIP_PCI.184.108.40.206
@Sebastian-Roth Sadly it just hung as well. Thanks for giving it a try though, I know compiling a kernel isn’t a 2 second process.
@JJ-Fullmer Ok, here we go, try this kernel: https://fogproject.org/kernels/Kernel.SR.SKIP_PCI.220.127.116.11
@Sebastian-Roth I also tried various old kernels from the fog kernel update (giving them different names of bzImage of course) non of which worked but had either similar errors or just hung.
So a special kernel is greatly appreciated.
@Sebastian-Roth Here is the full inventory that fog got on the tabtop
System Manufacturer HP
System Product HP Convertible x360 11-ab0XX
System Version Type1ProductConfigId
System Serial Number CND6381606
System UUID 75d38b44-b570-e611-b27e-98e7f4db4d7f
System Type Type: Notebook
BIOS Vendor Insyde
BIOS Version F.14
Motherboard Manufacturer HP
Motherboard Product Name 82E1
Motherboard Version 13.16
Motherboard Serial Number PGDJPF21U41RCZ
Motherboard Asset Tag Type2 - Board Asset Tag
CPU Manufacturer Intel® Corporation
CPU Version Intel® Celeron® CPU N3060 @ 1.60GHz
CPU Normal Speed Current Speed: 1600 MHz
CPU Max Speed Max Speed: 1660 MHz
Memory 3.69 GiB
Hard Disk Model
Hard Disk Firmware
Hard Disk Serial Number
Chassis Manufacturer Hewlett-Packard
Chassis Serial Chassis Serial Number
Chassis Asset <BAD INDEX>
So no it’s not an HP x2 210 tablet, but I wouldn’t doubt it’s got enough similarity to have the same problem being an HP x tablet.
@JJ-Fullmer Thanks for the pictures! I am fairly sure I know what is causing the hang on this device. Is this a HP x2 210 tablet??
I’ll compile a special kernel image for you that skips some PCI initialization code that is causing big troubles on some devices (namely that HP x2 210)!
Re watching the video I can see that you can’t really read any of the output as I set the resolution lower to be able to upload it faster. I’ll take some pictures of the output and post them shortly so you can actually read the error messages.
@Sebastian-Roth I suppose a kernel problem makes more sense than an efi boot file.
I gave your kernel a try, thanks for that, sadly it did not work and gave me a kernel panic. However it did get past that initial hang.
Here’s a video
I used the exact same adapter to image an asus tablet device right before trying to reimage this one.
This doesn’t mean much. One particular adapter may play well with one tablet but not with a different one. This is because the tablet’s (or PC’s or machine’s in general) firmware needs to have a driver for that specific network adapter.
In the video we see that iPXE seems to get an IP and load the kernel properly so I guess we see a hang in the Linux Kernel. Try using the
bzImage_rbkernel image from here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/0B-bOeHjoUmyMV095YVpsR3U5VFk
See if that helps.
@Tom-Elliott One video coming up. It’s hanging after it claims init.xz is loaded but then never leaves that screen to enter FOS. Here’s a picture of where it hangs
And here’s a link to the video from boot to hang
@Sebastian-Roth It has worked before, however I have a lot of the older ipxe and have tried them and they’re no longer working. I did attempt to install android x86 on this thing a while back, which didn’t work, hopefully that didn’t have some sort of unforseen consequence.
We have 2 startech USB21000S2 usb to ethernet adapters. In the video I run
load usb.efiin the efi shell which is a renamed version of the efi driver for this adapter. I have a link to it posted elsewhere in the forum. I used the exact same adapter to image an asus tablet device right before trying to reimage this one.
When you say hangs, do you mean it’s hanging at a certain point in the imaging process, or it never makes it into FOS?
If it makes to imaging and then hangs, where is it hanging?
If you could, see if you can take a video of the issue from boot until the point of hang, this may help us better see where and what the issue is.
@JJ-Fullmer You say this has worked before. Possibly a change in iPXE or the kernel is causing the hang. But I think we should start looking beyond that and ask what network adapter is being used? Are you sure using the exact same adapter?