Dual boot windows 7 & opensuse boot problem

[Wayne Workman]

@Thiago said in Dual boot windows 7 & opensuse boot problem:

All of our computers are dual boot system.
Some of them are Windows Vista/Debian, some Windows 10/Debian, Windows 10/Mint, Windows Vista/CentOS, Windows10/CentOS and so on.
Fog works correctly in all the cases.
How is your partition layout for opensuse (fs types)?
What is your fog version?

I think you should elaborate on YOUR setup lol!

[Sebastian Roth]

@ricky-ext We definitely need to know the exact partition layout. Boot opensuse and run sudo sfdisk -d /dev/sda and post the exact output here. If you installed windows and linux in UEFI mode then you might need to run gdisk -l /dev/sda

Then as well I might be able to figure out your bootloader setup if you could run the following commands and upload the generated binaries here in the forum as well: dd if=/dev/sda of=/tmp/sda.mbr bs=512 count=2048 and this one dd if=/dev/sda1 of=/tmp/sda1.mbr bs=512 count=2048 plus the same command but put your linux root (/) partition instead of sda1.
Then pack all those files into one compress tarball (tar cvzf /tmp/mbr_images.tar.gz /tmp/sda*) and upload the resulting file called “mbr_images.tar.gz” here in the forum.

[Thiago]

@Wayne-Workman
each lab with its configuration and its specific purpose.

@ricky-ext
the same layout here, 2 partitions for each system.(windows boot, windows system, swap, /)
i’m using grub to manage all.

[ricky.ext]

@Sebastian-Roth I think my previous setup wrong, so i creating from scratch my system. And i using vmware for my experiment.

When i run sudo sfdisk -d /dev/sda the output:

Here my “mbr_images.tar.gz” after follow your step -> https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4knU-eG9r1nVjlncEo3d2ZvUGc/view?usp=sharing

And this how i setup my latest system:

1. I install opensuse 11.4. Set a half of my hdd to extended, then i add “/” partition using ext3 and add “swap” partition. Ok, opensuse work perfectly.
2. Install windows 7. Make remaining unlocated partition for my windows. I just set 1 partition “C” only. Done, windows 7 work perfectly. But Bootloader didn’t show, by default my setup boot into windows 7.
3. Because my setup need dual boot os, so i need boot loader. Then i found easiest way that using EasyBCD. After success intall easyBCD to my windows, then i add new entry, on tab Linux/BSD and choose type bootloader GRUB(Legacy), and i let “Use EasyBCD’s copy of GRUB”, then i save my config in easyBCD. Done, dual boot work nice and perfect, windows 7 and opensuse.
4. I think my setup will work, so i creating image from that. With fog 1.2.0, i create new image with settings OS “Linux(50)” and image type “Multiple partition image - single disk”, this settings based on fog wiki. Finally, my system finished creating image of dual boot os.
5. I ready for deploying my image to client, and finally the deployment finished. First i choose boot from windows 7, and system success boot and work perfectly. Second i choose boot from opensuse, OMG opensuse work perfectly too, i think my experiment success bro.

How about my setup? Is that right or no? Thanks before bro.
And @Thiago, how about my setup bro?

[Sebastian Roth]

@ricky-ext Sorry to say this but I still find your partition layout a bit of a mess - but well that’s just my opinion. Your very first partition (sda1) is an extended one (or actually pointing to the extended partitions - sda5 and sda6 as linux calles those). As you see sda1 starts at sector 2048 and sda5 at 4096. Physically those extended partitions are not number 5 and 6 but 1st and 2nd! I am sure windows is showing you the extended partition(s) first in the disk manager tool.

As you proofed it’s definitely possible to install dual boot like this. But I’d never recommend having the extended partitions first because it can be confusing and could lead to human failures.

Next is the partition type of sda4. It’s FAT16 (id 6). How were you able to set this partition type. Did you really format this partition with FAT16? I doubt it. FAT16 is not made for such “big” disks/partitons and shouldn’t be used nowadays!

If it is working for you, you might just stay with it…

[Thiago]

@ricky.ext
this is from one of my images:

label: dos
label-id: 0x40c79279
device: /dev/sda
unit: sectors

/dev/sda1 : start=        2048, size=     2097152, type=27
/dev/sda2 : start=     2099200, size=   222398464, type=7
/dev/sda3 : start=   224497664, size=     1953792, type=82
/dev/sda4 : start=   226451456, size=    86128640, type=83, bootable

I don’t know if this is correct, but works for me.

[Sebastian Roth]

@Thiago There is no right or wrong as long as it is working for you guys. But yours definitely looks a bit cleaner to me. Although you might run into trouble with this hidden NTFS partition (sda1, type=27) if you want to use resizable image type. Not saying that you will, but possibly could…

Please tell us a bit more about your steps on installing the two OSes. I guess you installed Windows first and then linux. What about the bootloader. Which one are you using and how did you install it? Skipped GRUB install on linux install and added it into the windows loader by hand? Or did you let linux take care of the bootloader stuff when installing and everything just went fine?

[ricky.ext]

@Sebastian-Roth Thank you for your advice, okay i’ll follow your setup. Thank you for your help guys !

But, i have a new problem here,
When deploy dual boot image, using Unicast no problem, everything work perfect.
And when i deploy it with Multicast, there is a problem. I think when we used multicast mode, that cannot deploy SWAP partition. Or this is only happened to me?

After this i’ll follow your setup bro @Sebastian-Roth

[Sebastian Roth]

@ricky-ext FOG 1.2.0 is years old. I don’t remember exactly but possibly there was an issue with multicast and SWAP. I don’t know. We won’t fix this anyway. If you care about multicast (and I totally understand that you do!) then you need to update to the latest release candidate or wait till 1.3.0 will be released.

[Thiago]

@Sebastian-Roth
Yes, My image is not resizable…
I will try to reproduce my steps…
1 - Erase disk data/delete partitions
2 - Install Windows, reserving space for linux or shrink windows later (in disk management tool, or gparted if needed).
3 - Install Linux, install grub on mbr or partition.
4 - Configure grub if needed ( i had to make some minor changes only in Debian8/Windows10 because grub was listing windows 10 as 7)

My preference to use grub is because i can make changes in boot order, one time boot order and so on… easily using ansible or other management tool. I don’t know how can i achieve the same in Windows side.