Wake on LAN over different VLANS
-
@cml
I attempted to do that and by the image you see I tried exactly the same thing and the computer doesnt turn on.
I have wireshark but have never used the program to know how to filter to wol -
In wireshark first select your connection and then click start
Once started type wol into the filter box and click on apply.
This is what it looks like when I send a wol:
-
Ok i did exactly what you said. the top one is from a computer in the 10.1.x.x address and the bottom one which is the one that worked is from the 10.2.x.x address.
-
The top one is on the same subnet as your fog server correct?
Try running wireshark on the bottom machine (i assume it is on the same subnet as your target), but send the wol from your fog server.
-
@cml You are correct, the top one is on the same vlan as the fog server.
I just ran wireshark on the bottom machine and ran wol from the fog server and wireshark didnt pick anything up
-
Your switch is not forwarding the packets across subnets. Do you know what manufacture/model your L3 device is?
-
I thought this article was pretty good.
http://theithollow.com/2012/04/how-to-broadcast-across-subnets/ -
@cml My layer 3 device is Nortel 8010
-
Not familiar with Nortel’s configuration, but there is this post:
http://blog.michaelfmcnamara.com/2009/02/wake-on-lan-and-directed-broadcast/
-
@cml I double checked and we already enabled that portion of the switch and still nothing. But I did find a configuration on the switch from broadcast addresses and nothing is listed. Do you think if I entered the broadcast address there,the passport would then allow the packets to pass through the VLANs?
-
@szecca1 Try it and see.
-
@Wayne-Workman I put an email to my company because I didn’t want to try it and cause my entire network to go down. As soon as I hear from them I will give it a try
-
@szecca1 Better yet, see if you can get in touch with a Nortel person and see what they say about it. Or search their website for information.
-
@Wayne-Workman With this situation and me not being the network admin, my company would probably prefer me going directly to them first and then if possible calling Nortel. I will definitely keep you guys updated.
-
@Wayne-Workman said:
@szecca1 Better yet, see if you can get in touch with a Nortel person and see what they say about it. Or search their website for information.
I think you are saying that FOG requires that broadcasts be allowed to travel across the router to other VLANs.
This makes no sense - and even if it could be done - would not be advisable.
That’s what I’m being told, does this sound correct? -
@szecca1 said:
@Wayne-Workman said:
@szecca1 Better yet, see if you can get in touch with a Nortel person and see what they say about it. Or search their website for information.
I think you are saying that FOG requires that broadcasts be allowed to travel across the router to other VLANs.
This makes no sense - and even if it could be done - would not be advisable.
That’s what I’m being told, does this sound correct?You came to us with questions about how this is done, and we’ve helped you to the best of our abilities to troubleshoot, identify the problem, and guide you to accomplish what you’re wanting. It’s not our place to say what’s advisable and what’s not for you. Those kinds of decisions should be made by you and your network team.
We’re just here to help you do what you want, to help solve problems, etc.
But, I’ll tell you, it sounds like your network team don’t fully understand how the WOL plugin works, and I’ll tell you that YES, it can be done. And while the packet is a broadcast packet, it’s a packet destined for another network. It’s not broadcast throughout it’s source network, only it’s destination network. The router needs only to forward it, like we’ve pointed out. When it’s broadcast at the destination network, when those broadcast packets hit the router, because the destination network matches the source network, the router ignores it.
-
There is one alternative that I thought of…
You could use dedicated relays.
Relays are generally used to encapsulate a UDP packet (or any packet) into a TCP packet, send it to a relay on another network, then the receiving relay would then decapsulate the packet back to UDP, and then send it out.
I’ve seen this used for emergency broadcast systems before, it works well. I’m sure there are several software solutions that do it, both free and paid.
Then, you could just point the WOL plugin to the local relay. Ofcourse, this is just an alternative if your network team just doesn’t want to make a change. You could setup relays without help from the network guys. It’s not ideal and would require you to run a relay on some computer on each network (like a server)… but it’d work.
-
@Wayne-Workman First I want to apologize, I know you guys have worked hard to help me out and I could never repay you for all the help you have given so thank you very much. My company finally decided to work with me and we got it working in one building. They enabled direct broadcasts on both passports and now it is working fine. No one ever informed me that we had two passports which is fantastic. We are going to cleanup the switches and continue testing but seems like we may have figured it out, thanks to you guys!
-
@Wayne-Workman After we installed Fedora 21 server wake on lan no longer works even on the same vlan. I feel like i might have to install something but I can not find anything on the wiki. Would you be able to assist?
-
If you’re patient when I get home I can possibly help.
