Dell 7010 Lenovo L530 with UEFI enabled, won't network boot.

[Sebastian Roth]

@Wayne-Workman said:

I’ve also learned that the problem machine (optiplex 7010) needs fully shut off and re-started in order for it to use the new DHCP settings

Not only DHCP settings I reckon. I think I even had one of my machines reusing the iPXE binary it still had in memory. Had to switch it off and on again to make it request the file via TFTP again…

Did you get to try out the binaries? Any output??

[Wayne Workman]

https://drive.google.com/folder/d/0B2BmriqzYEgXQk5tbWczVVdZeEE/edit

One video hasn’t uploaded yet. When it does it will appear in this folder. The files are labeled by voice in the video.

[Sebastian Roth]

Can’t stop scratching my head today. EFI is really complex and I am sure I haven’t been able to understand even a tiny bit of it. The PC I am testing EFI PXE boot with is a Fujitsu ESPRIMO P910 E85+ which comes with the exact same NIC as you have in your DELL OptiPlex 7010 (Intel 82579LM!!). But EFI PXE boot is working on my machine (ipxe.efi, intel.efi, snponly.efi)…

So I checked your video again to see what debugging output we see right from the start. And there might be something interesting there:

iPXE initialising devices...Adding 3c509 root bus
Adding EFI root bus
MII PciRoot(0x0)/Pci(0x19,0x0)/MAC(90b11c9bc14f,0x0) is an MII device
MII PciRoot(0x0)/Pci(0x19,0x0)/MAC(90b11c9bc14f,0x0) is an MII device
SNP PciRoot(0x0)/Pci(0x19,0x0)/MAC(90b11c9bc14f,0x0)/IPv4(0.0.0.0) is an SNP device
SNP PciRoot(0x0)/Pci(0x19,0x0)/MAC(90b11c9bc14f,0x0)/IPv4(0.0.0.0) is an SNP device
NETDEV net0 registered (phys SNP-0xd07eb518 hwaddr 90:b1:1c:9b:c1:4f)
NETDEV net0 could not add SNP device: Error 0x7f45e082 (http://ipxe.org/7f45e082)

All the other messages about NETDEV rejecting duplicate ... might just be caused as it tries to re-add the device over and over again.

If I boot the my last uploaded ipxe.efi debug binary on the Fujitsu I get:

iPXE initialising devices...Adding 3c509 root bus
Adding EFI root bus
PCI 00:19.0 (8086:1502) has driver "82579lm"
PCI 00:19.0 has mem f7100000 io f040 irq 11
PCI latency timer is unreasonably low at 0. Setting to 32.
NETDEV net0 registered (phys PCI00:19.0 hwaddr 00:19...)
NETDEV net0 link is up
Adding EISA root bus
Adding ...
...
Adding PCI root bus
ok

So where is the difference? Why is your DELL 7010 not able to register it as an intel NIC and tries SNP which fails (snponly.efi is working on my Fujitsu as well by the way!)??

[george1421]

Well this is either good or bad. I get the same results as Wayne using 7010 bios A18.

Not sure if this has any bering on anything. But I checked into the dhcp discover and the 7010s are sending out arch type 7. I noticed that there are two different arch types. One is 7 and one is 9. There is also a arch 6 for 32bit. I guess the question I have is what is the efi boot kernel that is being built?

Type Architecture Name
---- -----------------
0 Intel x86PC (BIOS pre-OS environment)
1 NEC/PC98
2 EFI Itanium
3 DEC Alpha
4 Arc x86
5 Intel Lean Client
6 EFI IA32 (UEFI 32 pre-OS environment)
7 EFI BC (UEFI 64 pre-OS environment)
8 EFI Xscale
9 EFI x86-64 (UEFI 64 pre-OS environment)

[Wayne Workman]

@george1421 A18 won’t work according to this: http://www.dell.com/support/article/us/en/19/SLN296756/EN

I’m using A12 for the record.

[george1421]

A18 will work as long as you turn off the legacy ROMS. I did see that post too, btw. I just had to try it and it worked with the same results as you. So no better or worse then.

[Sebastian Roth]

Is anyone keen to try another binary (different debug options)? I somehow feel that we are not getting anywhere with this…

[Wayne Workman]

@Sebastian-Roth Sure.

[Sebastian Roth]

According to this http://ipxe.org/7f45e082 the error should be happening within efi_utils.c… 0_1448292948783_ipxe.efi (DEBUG=efi_utils)

[Wayne Workman]

@Sebastian-Roth
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsVUruALX8g

[Wayne Workman]

@Sebastian-Roth I noticed the very first two lines of output are unique.

I’ll try to get a clear picture of those.

[Wayne Workman]

@Sebastian-Roth This is as good as it’s going to get:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DrEReJwsdJc

[george1421]

@Sebastian-Roth I have was able to capture the screen and uploaded it here (since this is the first time I tried this process, the relevant information is about 50% of the way through the video. And the video is quite large because of the cruddy codec I used. As they say better next time:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/7t22wb4354njp56/1448293078345_ipxe_efi.avi?dl=0

One thing I noticed is your description 0_1448292948783_ipxe.efi did not match the downloaded file 1448293078345-ipxe.efi.

[Edit] FWIW this video doesn’t play well in VLC but it does in WIndows Media player. Sorry [/Edit]

[Sebastian Roth]

... is not a PCI device ... ??? Can you boot a live linux (in UEFI mode!) and see what you get from this command lspci | grep Ethernet

Can you get a clear readable picture of the first few lines? Would be interesting to see if there are different MAC and/or PCI addresses in that line…

[george1421]

This decidedly simple request has turned into a big PITA. I was able to boot the system with puppylinux but I think what I have on my flash drive is the 32 bit version. I’m downloading the 64 bit version to try to boot via cd in efi mode. Here is what I extracted from puppy linux in 32 bit mode with lspci -v
0_1448303778683_dell_7010b.txt

FWIW: The centos 7 rescue DVD (and centos 7) no longer uses lspci but pciutils (which is not available in rescue mode).

[Sebastian Roth]

Thanks a lot for the information and sorry for it being a quest! The output looks good to me (‘Ethernet controller: Intel Corporation 82579LM Gigabit Network Connection’). Downloading the video right now. Will let you know if I find something new in there. I just posted the issue in the ipxe forums. Hopefully we can get some help from them too.

Now that you are talking about 32/64 bit I wonder if this might make any difference. Here is a 32 bit binary (DEBUG=efi_utils 0_1448307858655_ipxe32.efi

[george1421]

@Sebastian-Roth No luck with the 32 bit version. It starts to load and then just kicks back to the Dell UEFI boot menu. I’m going to have to work on this later tonight. I’m learning more about uefi than I care to right now.

For a uefi boot from cdrom or usb flash drive the system must detect the uefi bits on the media or it won’t boot. That is why I can’t boot puppy linux via the uefi menu.

[Sebastian Roth]

@george1421 said:

For a uefi boot from cdrom or usb flash drive the system must detect the uefi bits on the media or it won’t boot. That is why I can’t boot puppy linux via the uefi menu.

Yeah, that’s definitely tricky. I haven’t fully understood all this yet. I wonder if there is an UEFI capable ISO file from iPXE that we could try. Seams like someone has thought about this before us: http://lists.ipxe.org/pipermail/ipxe-devel/2015-April/004095.html (shall I try adding the patch and building an EFI ISO)?

[george1421]

@Sebastian-Roth

I’m trying to remember the history with these Dells. It was either the 7010 or the 9020 we got hung up on with Windows deployment because the WinPE 2.0 environment didn’t have the drivers for the nic. We needed to upgrade to the next WinPE environment for it to have the drivers.

IPXE boot iso. I think the rom-o-matic had the option to create an iso image as well as a usb image. Im just wondering if the e1000 driver doesn’t support this intel nic. I have an older/different intel nic in this box in an expansion slot and that must not support uefi booting because I can’t select that card. I’m going to work on the linux/FreeBSD booting in uefi mode later tonight. Maybe I can glean more info on what hardware is installed.

[Sebastian Roth]

@george1421 said:

IPXE boot iso. I think the rom-o-matic had the option to create an iso image as well as a usb image. Im just wondering if the e1000 driver doesn’t support this intel nic.

Thanks a lot for working on this! rom-o-matic does generate ISO and USB images but I am pretty sure those are BIOS only. As you can see here the intel 82579LM NIC (PCI 8068:1502) is included in a driver called ‘intel’ within iPXE. There is no e1000 in iPXE only eepro100 for other cards: http://ipxe.org/appnote/hardware_drivers
A little earlier in this thread I posted that one of our UEFI machines (Fujitsu) has the same NIC (identical PCI ID) and is working as expected with the native iPXE intel driver. So I guess this is more a UEFI/OptiPlex issue than a NIC issue.