• I’d like to roll back the iPXE files only … say, 1.0.0+ ( 5d9fb )

    Is there a repository for such?

    I believe a problem I’m having is because of the iPXE and I’d like to test the theory.

    The problem is one that has had a lot of discussion but no firm resolution.

    Unicast works fine. Multicast works fine except upon system reboot after imaging. The dreaded sanboot hang, then HDD error on additional multicast attempts. Some have posted switching from AHCI to compatible, which is not a solution but a workaround and not preferred.

    Multicast worked on earlier kernels. I can roll back bzImage but what about iPXE?

  • In about a month’s time or so this whole conversation will be moot for me as I’ll be replacing the images with updated recipes captured via PartClone.

    If there is a bug and a solution I’m trying to find it not for my sake. I’ve already instructed our techs to use QuickImage and unicast in the meantime.

    If the PartImage-captured PartImage-deployed image has a sector problem when multicast, then would it not also be corrupt when it is unicast?

    Aggressively zero’ing the drives prior to PartImage Multicast results in the same.

    Interestingly, interrupting a PartImage-multicast session will corrupt the drive similarly to the point where FOG will refuse to work with that drive until it is re-zero’d.

  • Senior Developer

    While I’ve tried my best, and believe me when I say I really have, to maintain backwards compatibility, I have never been able to test all possible scenarios. That said is it more probable you’re running into a sector problem than an issue with partimage and multicast. Just saying.

  • These images were uploaded under Partimage and are PartImage images as created via an older FOG version (probably 0.32). They unicast as PartImage. The FLAG has been set since it was first available in 1.0.0 or whatever.

    The PartClone image was created 5 months ago, with whatever version of PartClone was in FOG at that time.

    By quoting from that article, if you are categorically saying the PartImage images cannot be multicast with the current FOG, then could you please update that article to say that in no-uncertain terms?

  • Developer

    Um hate to be the “Negative Nancy” but in [url]http://fogproject.org/wiki/index.php/Upgrade_to_1.x.x#Old_Images[/url] you will see:

    [*][B]Best practices:[/B] You should download these to your hardware and re-upload BEFORE deploying on to multiple machines. If [B]Image Type[/B] is set to [B]partImage[/B] on next upload it will automatically change [B]Image Type[/B] to [B]partClone[/B]. NO need to go back and change that setting. Once all your images are re-uploaded you can then go and disable [B]FOG_FORMAT_FLAG_IN_GUI[/B] in [B]Fog Settings[/B]
    [I][U][FONT=sans-serif][COLOR=#000000][B]There is a reason that is stated.[/B][/COLOR][/FONT][/U][/I]

  • Alrighty then. My first test with Multicasting a PartClone image succeeded. Any PartImage image continues to fail and fubar the HDD.

    Testing continues …

  • Developer

    [quote=“sudburr, post: 41196, member: 4706”]Would you consider building in the ability to allow to change the iPXE files post-install as well? They too have versions.[/quote]

    no. they have versions, but if the latest version doesn’t work for you, an older version almost certainly won’t.

  • Multicasting does transfer the image. Data transmission and HDD writing does occur.

    At first restart, before even attempting to boot from the HDD, I’ve booted to GParted and that’s where I see the imaginary partition table, instead of what should be there.

    The images tested are indeed set to PartImage. I will test with a PartClone image shortly.

    This server is running SVN2876 with iPXE 1.0.0+ (d38b) . It has never been 0.32 or 1.2.0, it was originally installed as SVN 2331 I believe, and updated maybe four times to land now at SVN2876.

    Looking at the trunk.tar … I see that the ipxe files come with. ( fog_trunk\packages\tftp\ ).

    You are forcing auto-download of the latest bzImage files when a new server is installed, but you do offer the means to download any bzImage kernel the user later desires from the FOG menus. Would you consider building in the ability to allow to change the iPXE files post-install as well? They too have versions.

  • Developer

    Just to back up Junkhacker here are the instructions to upgrade from 0.32 to 1.20:
    ]There you will notice [url]http://fogproject.org/wiki/index.php/Upgrade_to_1.x.x#Old_Images[/url]. Describing that partClone is the new method. partImage is no longer used since 0.33b. Due to this change your images will need to be set to “legacy”
    However, you state that unicast works and multicast does not. May I suggest to check the troubleshooting wiki:

  • Developer

    iPXE is NOT your problem.
    i also doubt that partImage is your problem, PartImage isn’t used unless you’re using images from versions fog prior to version 1.0.0
    what version of fog are you running?

  • Maybe I should rephrase my question.

    I’m not looking for FOG 1.0.0, I’m looking for the iPXE files. At least that is one thing I’m considering in tracking down the source of the problem.

    The problem being what I’ve seen other discuss, involving machines not rebooting properly after a multicast.

    Unicast in all its flavours works beautifully. Multicast used to work, but along the way has become an issue. The actual mechanic leading to the multicast, and the data transfer to clients works wonderfully, it’s at the first reboot after PartImage releases the system that everything goes pear shaped.

    And as I type this I wonder, is it PartImage’s fault in dealing with a multicast? hmm

    Anyways the initial problem screen stops at:
    /default.ipxe… ok
    [URL]http://x.x.x.x/fog/service/ipxe/boot.php[/URL]… ok
    booting from SAN device 0x80[/CODE]

    Subsequent reboots result in the same wordage.

    Attempting any other FOG based action on that afflicted system results in:

    • Mounting File System … Done

    • Checking Mounted File System … Done

    • Starting Image Push

    • Looking for Hard Disks …

    An error has been detected!

    Failed to initialize disk

    Computer will reboot in 1 minute


    FOG won’t touch this machine now. The drive must be wiped (typically with DBAN) or diskpart or whatever, because FOG can’t even run its own disk wipe. That last error persists.

    Changing the exit type makes no difference under the iPXE settings.

    I’ll admit I haven’t been able to fully test the multicast feature in a while, but it did work at one point. I don’t recall the version (bzImage or iPXE) but it did. And that was my first thought. That iPXE and its file were the culprit so I wanted to be able to replace with older versions.

    FOG has the built in feature for installing the kernel of your choice. I’m assuming that is for bzImage only and not iPXE. Or am I wrong? I have noticed that the iPXE version does change often, even if the bzImage does not.

    I rambled …

    To solve this problem I’m considering:

    • iPXE
    • bzImage
    • PartImage <— leaning towards this guy.
    • Use of the Hidden menu option with special key to enter

    … as possible causes.

    I reiterate, unicast works flawlessly. This is only a multicast issue.

    Disconnecting the network cable or interrupting the PXE DHCP call, results in either a disk read error or no further activity.

    According to GParted… All that exists on the HDD is a 54.91MiB Used, 1.95 GiB Unused and 147.05 GiB Unallocated. A neat trick. The original Windows 7 image had a single 70 GiB partition (no System Reserved partition at the head) with about 55GB of data.

    When I have more information I will move this into the Bug or Problems forum.

  • Developer

    1.0.0 was the first official release with ipxe included, though it was very basic.
    the problems you’re describing do not however sound related to ipxe at all with the possible exception of the choice of boot menu exit type, which you can change in fog settings

  • Developer

    The older files are still available on the Sourceforge page.


    There’s a link to 1.0.0, you can download the zip file and pull the ipxe files out of the packages\tftp\ folder, but I don’t think ipxe was included in 1.0.0 you will need to check the other versions, i know that 1.1.0 had ipxe files in the packages\tftp folder.

    However, if you are looking for the undionly.kpxe file, it can be found in fog version 1.0.0 in packages\tftp

    I assumed you were looking for ipxe.kpxe or some variant, please offer more information on the file you are looking for so we can help you to acquire it.

    bzImage files can be found in packages\web\service\ipxe\

    you just have to dig a little deeper.