Computer not join in domain with Samba4

[Sebastian Roth]

@danilopinotti Can you join that client by hand?

[danilopinotti]

@Sebastian-Roth Yes, manually i can do this

[Sebastian Roth]

Has it worked before with this client? Do other clients join nicely? We need more information…

[danilopinotti]

@Sebastian-Roth was apparently the firewall blocking some port Samba4

[Sebastian Roth]

Thanks for reporting back!

[Tom Elliott]

so this is now working?

[danilopinotti]

@Tom-Elliott Yes, it would be interesting if you stood it as a note in the WIKI

[Wayne Workman]

@danilopinotti said:

@Sebastian-Roth was apparently the firewall blocking some port Samba4

Firewall on what? The host, the server? What server? Where?

[danilopinotti]

@Wayne-Workman Our network architeture consists in a DMZ (Where found fog and samba4). We have a Physical Firewall (paloalto) and a switch core layer 3. The firewall was blocking almost all ports from Samba4 to client which causes the error

[Sebastian Roth]

@danilopinotti Well then I doubt you were able to join that client by hand! This was not caused by FOG…

[danilopinotti]

@Sebastian-Roth What do you mean by “Can you join that client by hand?”
From what I understood, you had asked if I had managed to put the machine in the domain manually

[Wayne Workman]

@danilopinotti

Sebastian was saying that if the firewall was preventing fog from joining a samba domain, then a manual join would also not work, which makes sense.

Can the client join successfully now?

[danilopinotti]

@Wayne-Workman
Yes, after open all ports, it works