PXE Boot HP X2 210 (Hybrid tablet Windows 10 Pro)

[Matthieu Jacquart]

@Sebastian-Roth Ok, I forgot to tell you but after taking pictures I’ve entered boot command and waited at least15 minutes, nothing happens
I’m going to test with bzImage_epk

[Matthieu Jacquart]

@Sebastian-Roth Something strange with bzImage_epk, it worked yesterday with previous efi file.

[Sebastian Roth]

@Matthieu-Jacquart Could you please try again. “Connection timed out” sounds a bit like the network or webserver on your FOG was not ready yet. Kind of weird but please try again. If you can do it with the bzImage binary then bzImage_epk should work as well (if it is still in place!).

Would be awesome if you can get a picture with a clean try using bzImage_epk and boot at the end. All debug messages readable. Then I will get in contact with the iPXE devs to see what ideas they have about it.

[Matthieu Jacquart]

@Sebastian-Roth Arf I’m stupid, I made a mistake one IP adress… I hate azerty keyboard
Let’s go for a last fresh try

[Matthieu Jacquart]

@Sebastian-Roth Ok last one !
No change for boot, even after 5 minutes

[Sebastian Roth]

@Matthieu-Jacquart Ok, great. Will see what the iPXE devs think about this… Will let you know soon.

[george1421]

@Sebastian-Roth I’m wondering if the efi environment needs to be able to understand the disk image and the .xz image is not understood. If I look at the rom-o-matic setting under image type the .xz format is not listed. But the other image test types (yellow in pict below) are. Since it can’t identify the .xz image it gives the format not recognized error. The format no understood command it troubling since someone put that test in the code, it makes me think its an important check.

It would be really nice if the ipxe developers could add a md5sum command to ipxe so we could ensure the image in memory has the same hash as the images on the FOG server. Right now there is no way to know if the image is getting corrupted in transit.

[Tom Elliott]

@george1421 To my understanding, iPXE doesn’t need nor care about the format of the file (gz, xz, bz2, lzma, etc…) as that’s handled when the kernel loads anyway.

[Sebastian Roth]

@george1421 I am pretty sure the .xz image format does not need to be understood by iPXE. This is handled by the kernel (later on in the process). See my post with the C comment a little further down! As well the message “format not recognized” does not play a roll for us. See the C code here if you like. This might be a minor print out bug in iPXE which does not cause any issue!

@Matthieu-Jacquart Meanwhile I compiled a new iPXE binary with some added custom debug output. Please put this in your /tftpboot and same procedure… hopefully we will see messages after boot!

[Matthieu Jacquart]

@Sebastian-Roth ok thaere’s some new info !

Do you want me tot test also with bzImage_epk binary (plus debug earlyprintk=efi) ?

[Sebastian Roth]

@Matthieu-Jacquart Thanks again! Sorry but this will be step by step as we just don’t really know where it starts hanging. Good to see that at least we now have some output after boot. No need to try bzImage_epk at the moment. Will probably upload the next ipxe binary in a few minutes…

[Sebastian Roth]

Here is a new one! Removed some of the debug statements (just saying so that you don’t wonder) and added some new ones. Please give it a try. Will hang again but we know better where.

[Matthieu Jacquart]

@Sebastian-Roth ok, 2 pictures, before and after “boot” command

[Sebastian Roth]

@Matthieu-Jacquart As we are waiting for an answer from the iPXE devs Tom had the idea that we could try an older version of iPXE just so see if this issue was introduced at some point. Here is a binary compiled from older source (from 02.02.2015).

I also thought about putting together a PXE-enabled grub or pxelinux EFI binary for you to see if this can netboot into FOG. But I dropped the idea because this would not be of much help for you when it comes to cloning those machines. We use iPXE to kind of remote control the clients when booting up - e.g. let them do some kind of task. And we cannot remote control grub or pxelinux easily.

[Sebastian Roth]

Just got a first answer from one of the devs. He suggested to add DEBUG=efi_wrap and so here is another binary that you can try. It might dump a lot of debug messages but that’s ok. Hopefully we end up with some new information…

Please try this as well as the binary from the old source I posted. Just to make sure!

[Wayne Workman]

@Matthieu-Jacquart Don’t give up. Guys like you are exactly what FOG needs to move forward. Your work with Sebastian is VERY appreciated by the whole fog community!

[Matthieu Jacquart]

@Wayne-Workman Thanks that’s nice, I really had impression to waste your time

@Sebastian-Roth ok, so first with old ipxe file

One strange thing is that this ipxe.efi file makes the tablet reboot after few minutes : first time I began to type command and make other thing, when I came back tablet had reboot, and second time while I was taking a picture before typing “boot” command. But once I’ve entered “boot” command, even after 30 minutes tablet always stays on prompt like in picture.

And with last ipxe file, I had debug=efi_wrap I hope it was ok
Before “boot” command

And after “boot” command

Much more text ! I hope it helps

Thanks again to all of you

[Sebastian Roth]

@Matthieu-Jacquart You are doing a great job! I really hope this will be fixed soon! So iPXE from an older source does not seam to be any better - good to know. Not sure what the rebooting is about.

One thing I notice in that output is GraphicsOutput. Maybe it’s just not able to print on the screen but still running. I kind of doubt but it’s possible. Could you configure a monitoring port on your switch to capture a packet dump of the tablet booting up using wireshark? We might see another DHCP request or some other noise from it.

@george1421 and @Wayne-Workman Do you want to give this iPXE binary a try as well? Any known working UEFI machine will do. Just as a reference to see if there is a difference in the output or what should be seen next. I guess you’d have to take a video. AFAIK some newer iPhones can take slow motion video. Would be awesome.

[Matthieu Jacquart]

@Sebastian-Roth Do you want me to test the ipxe file you sent to Georges and Wayne ?
For capturing packet dump, I don’t really know how to do that, do you have some tips ? I’ve installed wireshark but I don’t know how to specifically capture packet on one switch port…

[george1421]

@Sebastian-Roth said:

One thing I notice in that output is GraphicsOutput. Maybe it’s just not able to print on the screen but still running. I kind of doubt but it’s possible. Could you configure a monitoring port on your switch to capture a packet dump of the tablet booting up using wireshark? We might see another DHCP request or some other noise from it.

This thought may be in line with what I found with grub booting. I needed to add the function insmod efi_gop or the output was not visible on that e6220. As far as I could tell the FOS client was running just the screen output was not visible.

I will test the ipxe boot when I get in the office in about 2 hours.