New Forum Software

[Joe Schmitt]

Sorry about that, it would appear only a moderator can do that. (We’ve appointed a few to help out with this).

[Wayne Workman]

@Trevelyan said:

After a day of using it, I actually really like it - so long as you can find a way to redirect old forum links for anyone who might have hardlinked to threads here!

What does the forum use now?

I know that I hard-linked a TON to old forum posts.

[sudburr]

I’m not entirely sold on this new software and its interface. I’m finding it cluttered.

My biggest peeve right now is the sorting.

Viewing a forum post with more than a couple of replies is tedious.

Instead of viewing a simple ascending chronological list of post and replies from top to bottom, eg:

A post
b reply
c reply
d reply
pagination (which I’ve turned off for my probile)
e reply
f reply

This new style of:

A post
z reply
y reply
x reply
w reply
pagination
A post
v reply
u reply
t reply
s reply etc…

Forcing the user to the bottom of the last page/post then rescrolling back up through the posts and backwards through the pages (if pagination is turned on) is time consuming. I’m puzzled why this particular wheel was reinvented instead of sticking with the simple ascending chronological.

[sudburr]

Whoa… how do I edit an existing post of mine?

Don’t all cultures read top to bottom? I find reading bottom to top jarring and slow.

[sudburr]

I’m proving my own case. Okay, I found the sort oldest to newest. yay me. Now I can’t go back and remove my foot from my mouth that my initial reply induced.

Danger! Wil Robinson …

[sudburr]

I’m going to blame the 3 day old migraine I’m trying to think through… yah, that’s it.

[Tom Elliott]

@sudburr I agree that it’s a change and a large change at that.

What I love most about this forum over the old, beyond that we can keep updating it as it’s 100% free and opensource just like FOG is, is that it’s user customizable. We may setup defaults, but those defaults do NOT need to be what you must always follow.

I actually find the

A - Original post
z - Latest reply
y - reply before z
x - reply before y
..........

very much handy. Of course what I like isn’t what everyone is going to like. I enabled pagination simply because others are more comfortable with that style. The sorting is totally up to you, and even the pagination system is totally up to you.

[Wayne Workman]

I’ve gotten used to how the posts are organized.

I strongly dislike how search is performing.

[sudburr]

Okay, I’m now warming to the view style. I’ve set oldest > newest … and it is thankfully became a universal setting once I finished reading through every single thread I had already opened.

The top level topic and downstream topic screens I’m not so crazy about; but then I’m bypassing that altogether for reading by going straight to the unread instead.

I really, REALLY miss the ability to edit a post after posting.

[Joe Schmitt]

You can still edit a post. Click the three dots on the right of your post and click Edit.

[sudburr]

Aha! Thanx Jbob. I swear I clicked on it before and it gave me a `you can not upvote your own posts’. I must have slipped onto the ^ voting symbol.

< edit >
… and the crowd goes wild.