Dell Venue Pro 8 PXE boot issues
-
Hello,
I am running FOG 1.2.0. I am able to successfully deploy to several different types of machine and I have the DHCP options set in my windows DHCP server to point to the undionly.kpxe file in the tftp server.
When I tried to PXE boot my dell venue pro 8 (32 bit UEFI), it “succeeded to download NBP”, then continues on to the next boot device.
On the server side, in syslog I see some “client does not accept options” messages.
I tried the suggestions that I have seen around the internet of moving the efi files into /tftpboot/ and restarting the service. I had no luck with any of them when I configured the DHCP server to point at them. Is there anything I can do?
Thanks for any help you can provide,
Rob
-
There are several EFI files to try.
ipxe.efi
snp.efi
snponly.efiYou’ll need to change your DHCP option 067 to point to each one to try it (looks like you have a handle on that part). I don’t believe there’s any need to restart any services for changing your boot file, although you might want to double check your permissions for the files you move around. They should have the same as the others, like undionly.kpxe
Also, I’ve been heavily researching UEFI in the last month… 32bit UEFI support is sketchy at best… Maybe there’s a firmware update for this machine?
Let us know how it goes.
-
Thanks for your reply Wayne,
I have pointed DHCP at all the efi files you mentioned, and intel.efi, also undionly.kpxe.INTEL as I saw suggested in another forum on another site. No dice.
I changed all the permissions to the same as the undionly.kpxe file. Before that, I actually got an error message about reading the TFTP file or something, flashed very quickly. It seems like it gets the file now, but just ignores it.
Updated the firmware “bios” to latest revision “A10”. Unfortunately, still only 32bit.
I also tried plugging up to clonezilla, and it gets a tiny bit futher:
“Succeed to download NBP. Getting Cached packet. My IP is xx.xx.xx.xx”, then just hangs forever.
At this point, looking at WDS as a bandaid until I can get it working with FOG.
-
The last thing to check is to see if you can enable some sort of “Legacy” mode in the firmware of the target-device.
Look for stuff like “UEFI”, “BIOS”, “LEGACY”, “Compatibility”, and “Legacy Rom”.
Remember how it was before, and just poke around and see if you can change it from UEFI to BIOS. Then try the undionly.kpxe file with BIOS mode.
-
Ok, no legacy option on these unfortunately, even with safe boot turned off.
I did get on IRC with the iPXE channel, and they gave me a 32 bit ipxe.efi which I dropped into the tftp folder. It was able to get to the iPXE prompt I am familiar with. The file is attached, just change the extension to .efi
So next question is, is there a 32 bit efi binary that is programmed for FOG? It doesn’t seem to be an EFI issue, but rather a 32 vs 64 bit efi binary issue.
Thanks,
Rob[url=“/_imported_xf_attachments/1/1921_ipxe.txt?:”]ipxe.txt[/url]
-
OK, progress is good. We re-downloaded the i386 efi files from the sourceforge trunk tftp folder and deleted the old ipxe.efi just to be safe.
The new one seems to be working much better, maybe a copy error before?
Now the error is different, see the attached picture. Looks like maybe UEFI [32 bit] binary is not there? or iPXE can’t understand the menu[ATTACH=full]1923[/ATTACH]
[url=“/_imported_xf_attachments/1/1923_fog error uefi 32 boot.png?:”]fog error uefi 32 boot.png[/url]
-
You willing to try out SVN/Trunk?
-
Sure, how do I do that?
Also, I got this back from the iPXE IRC if it helps.
[COLOR=#000000][FONT=Consolas] topazdemon: it seems as though you don’t have PNG support enabled via IMAGE_PNG in general.h[/FONT][/COLOR]
[COLOR=#000000][FONT=Consolas][11:24] <mcb30> Even if you did enable it, there’s no support for graphical framebuffers in UEFI iPXE yet[/FONT][/COLOR]
[COLOR=#000000][FONT=Consolas][11:24] <mcb30> so you won’t be able to display the .png[/FONT][/COLOR]
[COLOR=#000000][FONT=Consolas][11:25] <topazdemon> ok, could that cause all subsequent activity to fail?[/FONT][/COLOR]
[COLOR=#000000][FONT=Consolas][11:25] <[COLOR=red]mcb30[/COLOR]> topazdemon: yes; iPXE scripts will exit on error[/FONT][/COLOR]
[COLOR=#000000][FONT=Consolas][11:26] <mcb30> If you want a specific script line to ignore errors, you have to indicate how errors should be handled[/FONT][/COLOR]
[COLOR=#000000][FONT=Consolas][11:26] <mcb30> e.g. “console -p bg.png ||”[/FONT][/COLOR]
[COLOR=#000000][FONT=Consolas][11:26] <mcb30> would say to ignore errors[/FONT][/COLOR] -
It’s that reasoning I request you to update as that is already handled
-
Ok, is there a certain file or group of files I should update, or is there a compiled install for trunk? Do I need to compile from source and reinstall?
And thank you for your reply Tom, I really appreciate your help
EDITI found the SVN on the Wiki, we are building another server to test
Thanks,
Rob -
As per SVN just download the latest trunk and rerun the installer.
-
[quote=“rball01, post: 46192, member: 29220”]Ok, is there a certain file or group of files I should update, or is there a compiled install for trunk? Do I need to compile from source and reinstall?
And thank you for your reply Tom, I really appreciate your help
EDITI found the SVN on the Wiki, we are building another server to test
Thanks,
Rob[/quote]You can follow this: [url]http://fogproject.org/wiki/index.php/SVN[/url]
-
Ok, we are making progress, so far we see the FOG menu now, and we can select boot to hard disk and that works.
but selecting any other option we first get two lines of text:
/bzimage
/init.xz…OKthen it cycles back to the menu. Selecting any option other than boot to hard disk after that shows
/init.xz…OK
Then back to the menu again and repeat
FOG does not seem to be honoring the FOG_PXE_MENU_TIMEOUT (always 3) and FOG_QUICKREG_AUTOPOP either - not sure if this is due to using SVN/Trunk
Thanks again for your help
-
[quote=“rball01, post: 46196, member: 29220”]Ok, we are making progress, so far we see the FOG menu now, and we can select boot to hard disk and that works.
but selecting any other option we first get two lines of text:
/bzimage
/init.xz…OKthen it cycles back to the menu. Selecting any option other than boot to hard disk after that shows
/init.xz…OK
Then back to the menu again and repeat
FOG does not seem to be honoring the FOG_PXE_MENU_TIMEOUT (always 3) and FOG_QUICKREG_AUTOPOP either - not sure if this is due to using SVN/Trunk
Thanks again for your help[/quote]
Set the hide-menu timeout and the menu timeout to 4 or 5.
Also, the menu might be “There” but the graphics controller and/or monitor just hasn’t started showing it yet because it’s changing over.As soon as you see “initializing devices” on the screen, start hitting the down arrow. This will “Catch” the menu.
-
We see the menu, but the different options are just looping back to the menu as described above
-
This might be a tough road to go down, but I think you ought to try to build your own files for 32 bit. You will probably need help from both the iPXE people, and the FOG Project’s own Tom and Uncle Frank.
There are instructions in the WiKi and in the Forum for building the files, but I’m not sure about x86. I’ve only built x64 and I struggled a bit with it. We have updated the WiKi and forum to reflect what had to be done to get it to work on Fedora/Ubuntu. I’ve also heard things about requiring a 32 bit system to compile 32 bit software in Linux… maybe I’m wrong… I have no idea.
Here are some links that I’ve found that may help:
[url]http://fogproject.org/wiki/index.php/Building_undionly.kpxe[/url]
[url]http://fogproject.org/forum/threads/build-ipxe-from-source.10152/#post-24197[/url]
[url]http://fogproject.org/forum/threads/dell-7010-lenovo-l530-with-uefi-enabled-wont-network-boot.12727/#post-45357[/url] -
Thanks Wayne, I think the issue is with bzimage and/or init.xz since I am seeing the FOG menu, but to be honest I don’t know what they are or if they are 32 bit
I think my ipxe issues may have been solved in the current trunk
I am hoping Tom will have a suggestion on where i can look for clues, I can post a video if it helps
Thanks again for your suggestions and help
-
rball01,
Please, if you can post a video feel free. It really is more helpful to know the full scope instead of just throwing out ideas.
-
Thanks, I will get a video capture first thing Monday morning and upload. I really appreciate the help, and I love FOG btw, killer product
-
Good morning, here is the video capture of the FOG menu behavior. Sorry it is sideways, not sure what the phone was doing. Wasn’t able to upload the MOV file, so you will have to download and change extension to MOV.
Thanks,
Rob[url=“/_imported_xf_attachments/1/1926_IMG_0595.txt?:”]IMG_0595.txt[/url]
