Only one computer in group

Zaarin

Hi All,

Trunk version 7559.

I tried to add several computers to a group, which exists or not, only the last one is added.

From the host managment or from the group management\Membership: The problem is the same.

If there is a computer in the group, it is removed and the last one of the new selection is added.

Thanks,

Zaza.

Tom Elliott

Unable to replicate. I went to Group->List All->Choose any group->Membership. Checked the hosts I wanted to add, all added successfully and were able to be removed and re-added and removed, just in case.

I also went to Host->List All->Select hosts I want in group->Choose group to “process group changes” and updated. All hosts I selected were able to be added successfully.

Zaarin

Hi,

Maybe this can help you. I tried again and same problem. This time, I took only two computers and tried from the HostManagement.

160510 14:38:33   179 Change user       root@localhost on
                  179 Query     SET NAMES utf8
                  179 Init DB   fog
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT `vValue` FROM `schemaVersion`
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT COUNT(`hosts`.`hostID`) AS `total` FROM `hosts` LIMIT 1
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SET SESSION group_concat_max_len=(1024 * 10)
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT TABLE_NAME FROM INFORMATION_SCHEMA.TABLES WHERE TABLE_SCHEMA = 'fog' AND ENGINE != 'MyISAM'
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `plugins`  WHERE `plugins`.`pInstalled`='1' AND `plugins`.`pState`='1'  ORDER BY LOWER(`plugins`.`pName`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_VIEW_DEFAULT_SCREEN'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_FTP_IMAGE_SIZE'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT COUNT(`hosts`.`hostID`) AS `total` FROM `hosts`WHERE `hosts`.`hostPending`='1' LIMIT 1
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT COUNT(`hostMAC`.`hmID`) AS `total` FROM `hostMAC`WHERE `hostMAC`.`hmPending`='1' LIMIT 1
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_DATA_RETURNED'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT COUNT(`users`.`uId`) AS `total` FROM `users` LIMIT 1
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT COUNT(`groups`.`groupID`) AS `total` FROM `groups` LIMIT 1
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT COUNT(`images`.`imageID`) AS `total` FROM `images` LIMIT 1
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT COUNT(`snapins`.`sID`) AS `total` FROM `snapins` LIMIT 1
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT COUNT(`printers`.`pID`) AS `total` FROM `printers` LIMIT 1
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_HOST_LOOKUP'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_MEMORY_LIMIT'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_FORMAT_FLAG_IN_GUI'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_SNAPINDIR'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_REPORT_DIR'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_TZ_INFO'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_TZ_INFO'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM users  WHERE uId='1'
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_INACTIVITY_TIMEOUT'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_REGENERATE_TIMEOUT'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_ALWAYS_LOGGED_IN'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_THEME'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `globalSettings`  WHERE `globalSettings`.`settingKey`='FOG_PLUGINSYS_ENABLED'  ORDER BY LOWER(`globalSettings`.`settingKey`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM taskTypes  WHERE ttID='2'
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM taskTypes  WHERE ttID='1'
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM taskTypes  WHERE ttID='8'
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM groups  WHERE groupID='1'
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `groupMembers`  WHERE `groupMembers`.`gmGroupID`='1'  ORDER BY `groupMembers`.`gmID` ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     INSERT INTO groups (`groupID`,`groupName`,`groupDesc`,`groupCreateBy`,`groupDateTime`,`groupBuilding`,`groupKernel`,`groupKernelArgs`,`groupPrimaryDisk`) VALUES ('1','Deploy Don Vista FR','','fog','2016-05-10 07:38:27','0','','','') ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE `groupID`='1',`groupName`='Deploy Don Vista FR',`groupDesc`='',`groupCreateBy`='fog',`groupDateTime`='2016-05-10 07:38:27',`groupBuilding`='0',`groupKernel`='',`groupKernelArgs`='',`groupPrimaryDisk`=''
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `groupMembers`  WHERE `groupMembers`.`gmGroupID`='1'  ORDER BY `groupMembers`.`gmID` ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `hosts`  LEFT OUTER JOIN `hostMAC` ON `hostMAC`.`hmHostID`=`hosts`.`hostID`  LEFT OUTER JOIN `images` ON `images`.`imageID`=`hosts`.`hostImage`   WHERE `hostMAC`.`hmPrimary` = '1' ORDER BY LOWER(`hosts`.`hostName`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `groupMembers`  WHERE `groupMembers`.`gmGroupID`='1'  ORDER BY `groupMembers`.`gmID` ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     SELECT * FROM `hosts`  LEFT OUTER JOIN `hostMAC` ON `hostMAC`.`hmHostID`=`hosts`.`hostID`  LEFT OUTER JOIN `images` ON `images`.`imageID`=`hosts`.`hostImage`  WHERE `hosts`.`hostID` IN ('3') AND `hostMAC`.`hmPrimary` = '1' ORDER BY LOWER(`hosts`.`hostName`) ASC
                  179 Query     SET SESSION sql_mode=''
                  179 Query     INSERT INTO groupMembers (`gmHostID`,`gmGroupID`) VALUES ('3','1') ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE `gmHostID`='3',`gmGroupID`='1'

Wayne Workman

@Zaarin There’s probably something in your DB that is breaking the process then. If you can use something like HeidiSQL or phpMyAdmin to put eyes on the actual data, maybe you’ll find something strange?

Tom Elliott

I’m moving this post to FOG Problems as this is not a bug.

My guess @Zaarin, your going to find your groupMembers table has a few either: gmID = 0, or gmGroupID = 0.

Zaarin

Sorry, I don’t know how to put a screenshot. A Show create table is better

CREATE TABLE `groupMembers` (
 `gmID` int(11) NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
 `gmHostID` int(11) NOT NULL,
 `gmGroupID` int(11) NOT NULL,
 PRIMARY KEY (`gmID`),
 UNIQUE KEY `gmHostID` (`gmGroupID`),
 UNIQUE KEY `gmHostID_2` (`gmHostID`,`gmGroupID`),
 KEY `gmHostID_3` (`gmHostID`)
) ENGINE=MyISAM AUTO_INCREMENT=5 DEFAULT CHARSET=latin1 ROW_FORMAT=DYNAMIC

This index seems to be wrong: UNIQUE KEY gmHostID (gmGroupID)

Is it the problem? I can remove it and test it but I wait your answer.

Thanks,

Zaza.

Tom Elliott

@Zaarin I don’t think it’s anything to do with the unique key. The idea of the one you believe is conflicting is that there only be one Host ID with a single group id. This way you don’t have

2 2
2 2
2 1

Pairings.

Tom Elliott

@Zaarin Further to add on, this is applied to the DB and I’m not seeing the same issue.

I really believe if you run:

SELECT * FROM `fog`.`groupMembers` WHERE `gmID`=0 OR `gmHostID`=0 OR `gmGroupID`=0 \G

Print the output of that here, and we should be able to see what’s going on a little better.

Wayne Workman

@Zaarin The problem is likely the data in the tables, not the tables themselves.

Zaarin

I removed the \G. Empy result is returned.

Tom Elliott

@Zaarin Why’d you remove the \G? That’s valid. And prints data much nicer especially when the output to the screen.

Can you get us a copy of the Statement with the \G AND without the WHERE clause(s)?

Zaarin

I agree with you for the unique key gmHostID_2 but not for the index: gmHostID. With that index only one group is allowed with one member.

\G is not recognized in phpmyadmin. I took the mysql console. Here is what you want.

mysql> SELECT * FROM `fog`.`groupMembers` \G
*************************** 1. row ***************************
     gmID: 1
 gmHostID: 6
gmGroupID: 1
*************************** 2. row ***************************
     gmID: 3
 gmHostID: 7
gmGroupID: 3
*************************** 3. row ***************************
     gmID: 4
 gmHostID: 2
gmGroupID: 4
3 rows in set (0.00 sec)

Thanks for your time,

Zaza.

Tom Elliott

@Zaarin No, it’s not. If it were the case, ALL users of trunk would be seeing EXACTLY the same problems.

Maybe the issue is the schema that performed didn’t update properly? I don’t know.

You can try to alter the unique indexes if you want though. I don’t know what you’d do. Maybe for now just remove the unique index’s and keys?

Tom Elliott

@Zaarin What version of MySQL are you running?

Zaarin

5.5.49-0ubuntu0.14.04.1

I had problem with database update but it was some version before. I agree with you that all users will see exactly the same problem.

The only way to check is to compare with yours: Do you have the same structure?

Once again thanks for all your time,

Zaza from Luxembourg.

Tom Elliott

@Zaarin

CREATE TABLE `groupMembers` (
  `gmID` int(11) NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `gmHostID` int(11) NOT NULL,
  `gmGroupID` int(11) NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`gmID`),
  UNIQUE KEY `gmHostID` (`gmHostID`,`gmGroupID`),
  UNIQUE KEY `gmHostID_2` (`gmHostID`,`gmGroupID`),
  KEY `new_index` (`gmHostID`),
  KEY `new_index1` (`gmGroupID`)
) ENGINE=MyISAM AUTO_INCREMENT=19 DEFAULT CHARSET=latin1 ROW_FORMAT=DYNAMIC

Tom Elliott

@Tom-Elliott The only difference I see is the KEY’s aren’t adjusted for in yours where mine is.

Zaarin

I alter the table indexes like yours. It works like a charm now. I have my 7 computers in one group.

This topic can be closed.

Thanks you,

Zaza.

Wayne Workman

@Tom-Elliott said in Only one computer in group:

Why’d you remove the \G? That’s valid.

Not on every system. I’ve had it throw syntax errors before.

A Former User

I’ve been getting the same problem with a fresh install on an ubuntu 14.04.3 x64. I used the git trunk version.
The only way I find to get rid of it is to delete the table groupMembers and recreate it with the create table find here. The other way for a fresh install is to install the stable 1.2.0 version first (which create the database) and installing the trunk version after. There is something with the database creation of the git trunk version. I repeated it today and I got the same issue.

Only one computer in group

274

11.7k

17.1k

154.6k