Fog PXE Boot issues in VMware
-
I have open a ticket with VMware and they say it is not there issue. I can not boot from VMware workstation pro. I have bios set to UEFI. Not sure why. I am on windows 10. I have tried bridged and nat. I am unable to get it to pxe boot. It stops at the screen and says start pxe over ip4. I am not sure why. I know I can reboot the computer and then to the setup screen and I can select uefi network boot ip and it works fine. I just do not know why UEFI is not working in VMware workstation. Has anyone seen this. I can push an image out all day using fog. I just can not upload one from vmworkstation. Is there a bootable fog image iso that I can try ?
-
@george1421 I have finally got it resolved. I went back to vm workstation support and they updated a file in their install . Then it magically started to work
They think the install file was corrupt on their side
Too odd.
Thanks everyone helping
I was running the latest build on version 15
-
I have done this before in the past on an older fog server with no issues. I have even turned that one on and get the same message when using vmworkstation. I am at a loss when it works on a normal computer .
-
I’m not understanding your question.
What version of FOG are you using?
What Boot file is VMWare Workstation trying to use to UEFI Network Boot?My best guess, with the limited information I have, is that you haven’t told VMWare Workstation to boot to ipxe.efi.
I would highly recommend you use a bridged network as NAT network you essentially tell your machine, for lack of a better term, to use the Virtual Switch VMWare provides in a natted environment. This could make the network the Workstation is talking to, incapable of accessing the actual network your FOG server is distributing across.
At this point, I want to say this is NOT a FOG issue, and it likely is NOT a VMWare issue, but rather a networking issue. Either it’s how the network is getting to the VMWare Workstation Machine or it’s how the network is communicating from the FOG server to the point where the network touches your VMWare Workstation machine. (It really sounds like a networking issue, but I don’t know where to lead you to help out more directly.)
-
I am sorry I am on an isolated network. Just a unmanged switch. I can boot any computer hooked up and pxe works like a champ to push the image. The only issue that I run into is uploading an image to the fog server. It gets stuck on that screen. I have tried bridge and nat. None of them work.
I was wondering if fog had an iso that I can try to boot from to get to the fog server. I am running latest version of fog and it works fine if I boot a computer and image it. I have not tried an upload to it. I can not even get it to boot from the vm to drop and image in the vm.
-
@mmoore5553 That’s what makes me think networking is the problem. As you’re saying this is happening on a VMWare Workstation, this make me think the installation is not bridging to the “real” network adapter that is connected to the managed switch.
I’d almost guess that the machine you’re running VMWare Workstation from probably can’t even boot into fog?
There is means to do USB booting, but I don’t know how to translate that to VMWare Workstation, it’s not even something I fully support (though I’m not afraid to lead a horse where it needs to go.)
This is made by @george1421: https://forums.fogproject.org/topic/7727/building-usb-booting-fos-image
-
@mmoore5553 What version of vmware workstation are you using? I’m running VM Workstation v11 on my system.
Please help us build the FOG community with everyone involved. It's not just about coding - way more we need people to test things, update documentation and most importantly work on uniting the community of people enjoying and working on FOG!
-
@Tom-Elliott if I reboot the computer it will find fog fine. No issues there at all. Just when I am in vmworkstation pro. it is VM software like virtualbox.
-
@george1421 I can pxe boot into the fog iPXE menu using VMWare workstation 11 with the target computer in EFI mode from a cold boot only. When I try a warm boot the vm gets stuck like Virtual box does. Cold boot the vm and it boots into iPXE. This is an issue with the hypervisor not FOG. When I develop my golden images, I use ESXi and there is never an issue with network booting cold boot or not.
Edit: Well maybe it only worked the very first time I setup the VM. Subsequent tries gives me a timeout error and throws me to the EFI boot manager.
Please help us build the FOG community with everyone involved. It's not just about coding - way more we need people to test things, update documentation and most importantly work on uniting the community of people enjoying and working on FOG!
-
@george1421 After trying this, that, and the other thing… I’ve come to the conclusion that pxe booting a vmware 11 client in uefi mode is problematic at best. Its totally random when it wants to network boot or not. It WILL boot consistently in bios mode warm or cold boot.
I imagine that one could create a uefi iso image and boot it that way into fog if you needed a uefi base image. It should be that hard to do. You will just need ipxe.efi from the /tftpboot directory on the FOG server and a few minutes of time.
-
@george1421 I have finally got it resolved. I went back to vm workstation support and they updated a file in their install . Then it magically started to work
They think the install file was corrupt on their side
Too odd.
Thanks everyone helping
I was running the latest build on version 15
-
@mmoore5553 @george1421 I can confirm that it is hit or miss. It is very annoying. I would put the image on exsi but we have to have it on an isolated network. I just find it odd since this just started happening and i never had it before. I was using version 12 before but then it started doing the issue. Now I am back to not getting it to boot.
Something i really hate being the guy that maintains the golden image.
-
@mmoore5553 PXE booting from a cold boot worked more often than not. But I agree its pretty annoying.
I have not tried this but if you make a uefi iso image you may be able to boot into ipxe pretty reliably. As I posted before you will need ipxe.efi from the fog server and then just manually create the uefi disk structure and rename the ipxe.efi to boot64.efi (you will need to confirm the actual uefi boot file name) then create your iso image. Configure your vm to boot from the uefi disk and it should launch ipxe and the fog menu. That will bypass the entire pxe part of the process.
-
@george1421 i am lazy. I can paypal you some money if you make the iso for me LOL . Just let me know how much.
-
@mmoore5553 I’m basically lazy on the weekends too. https://forums.fogproject.org/topic/6350/usb-boot-uefi-client-into-fog-menu-easy-way
https://mindthebandgap.wordpress.com/2013/03/13/how-to-convert-bootable-usb-into-an-iso-file/
Basic concepts. -
@george1421 i made a usb boot disk but run into errors there too. This is a pain. I do not know how i am going to get my golden image updated. Here is the error i get
if i just boot the usb drive and computer. I get connected and IP address but then it says it can not find an image when i select it. UGH .
-
@mmoore5553 OK so iPXE is running. The error message says that its not getting an IP address on the interface identified by the mac address.
So, I have to ask the question(s)
- For this VM, is it connected by a bridged interface to the physical network adapter?
- For the network where this VM is connected; what device is your dhcp server?
- Is your FOG server on the same subnet as this VM?
- What do you have configured for dhcp option 66 and 67?
My intuition is telling me you have an infrastructure issue, not necessarily a fog issue. You say that physical computers pxe boot without issue. I’m almost thinking its on the vm networking side.
If the fog server is on the same vlan as the pxe booting VM we might be able to use the fog server to find out what is being sent by the client computer.
-
@george1421 my setup is simple. I have a computer that is connected to netgear switch. It is an unmanaged switch. It then connects to the fog server . That is the only computers on this switch. We do not have it on a network at all but this isolated network. I have never ran into this issue. Before i brought it here it was pushing out images all day when you pulled the image- booting a computer up and then pulling the image from the fog server. One thing I did notice on the fog server that it is not putting a gateway in IPconfig. Not sure why. I am going to pull out my old laptop fog server . Do i need to get the special file off of it ? or are those files the same from server to server. That fog server is 1.0.5
-
@mmoore5553 So you have just a simple network setup, only a vm host server, a network switch and a fog server. What is your dhcp server for this network? Do you have the fog server issuing dhcp addresses to the target computers?
-
@george1421 yes the fog server should be handling dns and dhcp. The computer gets an ip address each time and dns. I have a spare fog server i am booting up now but it had the same issues before .
-
@mmoore5553 Understand I’m still trying to get the picture of what is not working here; so physical machines get their IP address no problem when plugged into the unmanaged switch. The only issue is with the virtual machine running under vmware workstation?
